Apple’s EU DMA test hinges on new fees and browser rules as Brussels weighs compliance case
Daniel Simon ·
Apple’s compliance plan for the Digital Markets Act is under formal review in Brussels after a year of regulatory and developer pushback. At issue are new commercial terms and technical gates that critics say replicate the App Store’s economics under a different label.
The European Commission opened noncompliance proceedings on March 25, 2024 against Apple related to steering, alternative distribution and browser choice. The case file cites Apple’s new Core Technology Fee and conditions for alternative app stores and browser engines as potential barriers to effective switching and competition.
Apple’s EU terms introduced a 0.50 euro per annual install Core Technology Fee for apps that exceed one million first installs in a 12 month period. The fee applies to developers that opt in to new distribution paths or payment options. Apple’s developer documentation published in January 2024 outlines the fee and the eligibility rules for alternative app marketplaces.
Developers and rivals argue the structure neutralizes the DMA’s promise of lower prices and more choice. Spotify chief executive Daniel Ek called the fee a circumvention in a January 2024 statement. Epic Games submitted filings to the Commission and publicly argued that the cost model and approval process for third party stores remain impractical for most software vendors.
Browser makers have raised parallel concerns. Mozilla’s public analysis in March 2024 said Apple’s new entitlements for non WebKit engines in the EU come with technical and process constraints that raise costs for alternative engines. Apple’s documentation requires engine providers to maintain separate EU only binaries and comply with additional review conditions.
Regulatory risk is acknowledged in Apple’s securities disclosures. Apple’s Form 10 Q filings in 2024 flagged the DMA and other digital platform laws as potential material risks to services revenue and operating margins. The company has defended its plan in public statements and says the new terms expand choice while protecting user security and privacy.
The Commission has signaled that pricing structures and technical design are within scope. In its March 2024 case announcement the Commission said it would assess whether Apple’s terms enable effective steering to offers outside the App Store and whether conditions for alternative app stores and browser engines are fair and proportionate. The DMA allows fines of up to 10 percent of global turnover and up to 20 percent for repeat infringements.
The stakes are significant for developers and consumers. A per install fee layered on top of third party payment processing can limit price reductions that the DMA sought to unlock. Restrictions on browser engines and distribution pathways can entrench incumbent defaults and reduce pressure on platform fees.
What happens next will set a template for DMA enforcement. The Commission can issue a noncompliance decision after its investigation and impose behavior remedies or fines. Parallel probes into other gatekeepers are ongoing, but Apple’s case will test whether fee shifting and design friction pass muster under the law’s interoperability and fairness requirements.