Amazon’s rising seller fees and ad taxes face new scrutiny as FTC case advances
Daniel Simon ·
Amazon’s marketplace economics have shifted in ways that are not visible in quarterly headlines. The Federal Trade Commission’s antitrust suit and Amazon’s own disclosures point to a rising take from merchants built on fees and ads that now underpin the retail business.
The accountability question is whether those costs reflect competition on the merits or platform leverage that dulls price competition. The answer matters for millions of sellers and the effective prices consumers pay.
What the filings show
In an amended and partially unsealed complaint filed in federal court in 2024 in FTC v. Amazon.com, Inc., the agency cited internal programs that raised prices across the market. The filing described Project Nessie, an algorithmic pricing strategy that the FTC alleged generated more than one billion dollars in excess profit before Amazon halted it, according to the complaint.
Separate from pricing algorithms, Amazon has layered on logistics and placement costs. In 2024 the company introduced a low inventory level fee and other Fulfillment by Amazon adjustments, detailed in Seller Central notices published in January 2024. Those changes added to referral fees and storage charges that sellers must navigate to maintain the Prime badge.
Amazon’s own numbers capture the shift. In its 2023 Form 10-K filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission, Amazon reported 140.7 billion dollars in third party seller services revenue and 46.9 billion dollars in advertising services revenue. Both lines grew faster than first party retail, highlighting a model that monetizes access to shoppers and fulfillment capacity.
Independent research aligns with that picture. Marketplace Pulse, a research firm that tracks marketplace data, estimated in an April 2024 analysis that sellers now remit more than half of each sale to Amazon when combining commissions, fulfillment, and advertising needed for visibility.
Who pays and how
The mechanics affect market structure. Sellers report that ad spend has become a toll to retain search placement as paid units compete with organic results. Logistics fees penalize deviation from Amazon’s inventory norms, which can disadvantage smaller merchants with volatile demand or seasonal goods.
For consumers, the costs do not show up as a line item. If sellers pass through higher fees, effective prices rise or selection narrows as low margin products become uneconomic. The FTC’s theory of harm links those dynamics to platform rules that foreclose alternative fulfillment and steer traffic to Amazon’s paid placements.
Regulators in other jurisdictions have scrutinized similar tactics. The UK Competition and Markets Authority has examined online marketplace self preferencing and the role of paid placements, and the European Commission has pursued cases related to marketplace bundling and competition on the platform’s own storefronts.
The stakes are not limited to one company. Walmart Marketplace, Temu, and TikTok Shop are expanding with their own fee stacks and ad products. The standards set in the Amazon case could shape what is considered lawful when platforms control logistics, ranking, and access to demand.
What happens next will play out in court filings rather than press releases. Pretrial motions and discovery in the FTC case are ongoing, and the agency is seeking conduct remedies that could include limits on fee tying and greater transparency on ad ranking. If the court finds liability, the order could reset how much of each online sale goes to the platform versus the merchant, with implications for prices across ecommerce.