Amazon’s ad-first marketplace shifts costs to sellers and shoppers, filings and research show
Daniel Simon ·
Amazon has turned its core marketplace into an advertising engine that pushes costs onto sellers and shoppers. Regulatory filings and independent research show ads and logistics fees now sit at the center of how products surface and what they cost.
Amazon reported $46.9 billion in advertising services revenue in 2023, according to its Form 10-K. The company told investors that ad products improve discovery and relevancy for customers, and it reported double digit year over year growth in advertising services in the first half of 2024 in its quarterly filings.
Marketplace Pulse, a research firm that tracks seller economics, found in January 2024 that a typical merchant using Fulfillment by Amazon and paid ads can see all-in fees approach half of the item’s selling price. Amazon introduced new inbound placement and low inventory level fees for FBA in 2024, according to Seller Central notices, which sellers say they factor into pricing both on and off Amazon.
The Federal Trade Commission and 17 state attorneys general sued Amazon in September 2023 in the Western District of Washington. The complaint alleges Amazon penalizes merchants that offer lower prices elsewhere, conditions visibility and Prime eligibility on its paid logistics, and steers shoppers toward higher priced listings.
In an unsealed version of the complaint in April 2024, the FTC alleged Amazon previously used an algorithm internally called Project Nessie to raise prices industrywide until 2019. The agency seeks a permanent injunction that could bar the practices it says harm competition, including anti discounting measures and steering driven by paid placement.
H2: What the filings show
Amazon’s investor reports separate advertising services from retail and third party seller services, which include FBA and referral fees. Advertising has grown faster than the retail business and carries higher margins, a trend reflected in Amazon’s segment disclosures and discussed on earnings calls throughout 2023 and 2024.
Independent audits have documented what this looks like for shoppers. A 2022 analysis by The Markup found that sponsored listings often dominate the first screen of results for common shopping queries, with multiple ad units interleaved with organic results. The FTC complaint cites Amazon’s increasing reliance on paid placements as part of the competitive theory of harm.
Amazon has said publicly that ads help brands reach interested customers and that FBA fees fund nationwide logistics that meet fast delivery promises. In its filings, the company frames these programs as optional and designed to improve the customer experience.
H2: Who pays and what happens next
The stakes run through the consumer economy. Merchants pass rising ad and logistics costs into prices to maintain margins, according to Marketplace Pulse’s 2024 analysis and seller advisories. Shoppers encounter more sponsored results and fewer low price signals if sellers avoid discounting elsewhere to keep Amazon algorithms favorable, as described in the FTC’s complaint.
The antitrust case remains pending in federal court in Washington State. The FTC is seeking a court order that would bar Amazon’s alleged anti discounting, tying, and steering practices. If granted, it could force structural changes in how search results surface, how Prime eligibility is awarded, and how sellers price across the web, with direct effects on fees, ad spend, and consumer prices.